| Donald Rumsfeld PRIN4th |
| Semifinal | ||
| Ed Rooney CUSE | PIN 2:00 | Dale Ward ARMY |
| Ed DeWitt PITT | DEC 8-3 | Donald Rumsfeld PRIN |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Donald Rumsfeld PRIN | DEC 8-1 | Tom Chrystie COLU |
| Ed DeWitt PITT | DEC 5-0 | Walter Farrell COR |
| Ed Rooney CUSE | DEC 8-1 | Edward Noe PENN |
| Dale Ward ARMY | DEC 9-7 | Hugh Chandler HARV |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Donald Rumsfeld PRIN | PIN 5:13 | Tom Herr FM |
| Ed Rooney CUSE | PIN 6:53 | Dick Whited LEH |
| Dale Ward ARMY | PIN 4:03 | Worth David YALE |
| Tom Chrystie COLU | DEC 4-3 | Tom Peschel RU |
| Ed DeWitt PITT | DEC 4-0 | John DiFiore TEMPLE |
| Walter Farrell COR | DEC 6-5 | Phil Brainerd NAVY |
| Edward Noe PENN | DEC 12-9 | Bill Shawley PSU |
| Hugh Chandler HARV | DEC 7-0 | Jim Harrell BRWN |
