| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Joe St. George YALE | PIN 3:41 | Abraham Allan ARMY |
| John McClure CUSE | PIN 6:44 | John Adams COR |
| Dan Ray HARV | PIN 5:52 | John Semple United States Coast Guard Academy |
| Russ Randall | ||
| UNVERIFIED 8-2 |
| Charles Gilmore Dartmouth College |
| Jack Sullivan PENN | UNVERIFIED | Ernest Closser PSU |
| Roy Zackey LEH | PIN 5:15 | John Dreyer COLU |