| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Bill Sargent YALE1st | — | Charles Eisenman PSU2nd |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Paul Lee PENN | UNVERIFIED | George Benner LEH |
| George McConnell COR | UNVERIFIED | Alexander PRIN |
| Bill Sargent YALE | UNVERIFIED | Charles Eisenman PSU |
| Crowe CUSE | UNVERIFIED | Hubert Relyea COLU |
| Paul Lee PENN | UNVERIFIED | George McConnell COR |
| Bill Sargent YALE | UNVERIFIED | Crowe CUSE |